All Hallows’ Eve, better known as Halloween, was especially dark and scary in Amarillo, TX on October 31st, 1991. There definitely weren’t any treats to be had, and the trick this year, was murder. But this one was especially heinous, as Sister Tadea Benz, was raped, stabbed, and strangled inside her second floor bedroom in the St. Francis Convent while she slept. Things aren’t always what they seem, even when the evidence, or a clairvoyant, point you in the direction of the killer. Listen and find out more about the people and things that go bump in the night. Episode 54.

(Get early ad-free access to weekly episodes – as well as exclusive monthly episodes – by subscribing to our Patreon https://www.patreon.com/sleuthbetold)